Heidi Klum is very passionate about her sandwiches but they have an unexpected ingredient.
The âAmericaâs Got Talentâ judge posted a video on her Instagram Story on Sunday revealing that she adds butter to her bread before adding peanut butter and jelly.
She said in her video, âSometimes this just hits the spot.â The 50-year-old model also shared another video of herself making a sandwich with bread already covered with butter on one side as she was adding peanut butter.

Seems like PB&Jâs are one of her favorites because she explained in the video, âWhen I first came to America, I didnât know what the obsession was. Now I am obsessed myself. Donât worry, Iâll eat the crust.â
Access Hollywoodâs Zuri Hall spoke to Heidi following Tuesday nightâs part 1 of the two night finale of âAmericaâs Got Talentâ where she doubled-down on her love for butter on sandwiches and passionately explained her reasoning for adding it.
âI put butter on all of it, it doesnât matter if itâs peanut butter, salami, cheese, Philadelphia, it doesnât matter, you put butter on it,â she explained.
âBread has all little holes on it, this is how you close all the holes and then itâs all shut and it has a nice schmear to it and then you put toppings on it. You need to close all the holes,â she continued.
Adding, âI was shocked that none of you putter on your bread.â
Leave it to Heidi to find another way to show off her great taste!
The âAGTâ judge also teased her upcoming epic Halloween costume and revealed her husband Tom Kaulitzâs reaction. She also shared that the coupleâs look are ânot matching but weâre cohesive, letâs say.â
Part 2 of the âAmericaâs Got Talentâ finale airs Wednesday night at 8 PM on NBC.
Copyright Š 2026 by NBC Universal, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
This material may not be republished, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.